Key Facts
- •Four appeals against refusals by Crown Court judges to make confiscation orders due to exceeding the two-year time limit under section 14 of the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002.
- •Appeals relate to unrelated cases, but share the same legal issue.
- •Significant delays caused by the COVID-19 pandemic and Criminal Bar Association action.
- •Court backlog and challenges with the digital case system contributed to delays.
- •Cases involved various complexities, including multiple defendants and lengthy proceedings.
Legal Principles
The Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 imposes a duty on the court to proceed with confiscation, not on other parties.
Soneji and Guraj
The two-year time limit in section 14 limits the time between the duty to proceed (section 6) and the conclusion of proceedings, not the point at which that duty arises.
Soneji and Guraj
The two-year period can be extended in exceptional circumstances, regardless of whether an application was made before expiry or not.
Soneji and Guraj
Compliance with section 14 is not a condition precedent to jurisdiction; jurisdiction is retained until proceedings are determined under section 6.
Soneji and Guraj
Non-compliance with section 14 may affect the fairness of the order, potentially leading to an abuse of process (though rare).
Waya, Soneji
"Exceptional circumstances" should be broadly interpreted.
Soneji
Prosecutorial misconduct can constitute exceptional circumstances.
Overruling of Anthony Smith
Outcomes
Appeals allowed in all four cases.
Crown Courts misdirected themselves on the interpretation of section 14, failing to recognize exceptional circumstances due to pandemic, CBA action, and court inefficiencies.
Crown Courts directed to proceed afresh, not restarting from scratch but continuing from the point of refusal.
Court retains jurisdiction, and exceptional circumstances justify extension beyond the two-year period.
Time extensions granted for the appeals.
Exceptional circumstances justify the extensions.
Cases to be relisted within 28 days for further directions and hearing dates.
To ensure timely resolution without avoidable delay.