Key Facts
- •Stephen Whiteside challenged the London Borough of Croydon's approval to discharge condition 18 of planning permission 21/0919/FUL.
- •Condition 18 related to finished land levels, while condition 14 required accessible housing compliant with Building Regulations 2010.
- •Whiteside argued the discharge of condition 18 made compliance with condition 14 impossible, rendering the approval irrational and breaching the PSED.
- •The council argued that condition 18's purpose was separate from condition 14 and that compliance with building regulations was a matter for building control.
- •The court considered whether the council should have considered the potential impact of discharging condition 18 on condition 14.
Legal Principles
Irrationality/Wednesbury unreasonableness in planning decisions.
R (Christine Wells) v Welwyn Hatfield Borough Council [2022] EWHC 3298 (Admin)
Duty to carry out sufficient inquiry.
R (Plantaganet Alliance) v Secretary of State for Justice and others [2014] EWHC 1662
Interpreting planning conditions.
Trump International Golf Club Scotland Ltd v Scottish Ministers [2015] UKSC 74
Approach to material considerations in planning decisions.
R (Samuel Smith Old Brewery (Tadcaster) v North Yorkshire County Council [2020] PTSR 221
Public Sector Equality Duty (PSED) under section 149 of the Equality Act 2010.
Equality Act 2010, section 149
Building Regulations 2010 and Approved Document M.
Building Regulations 2010, Building Act 1984
Test for discharge of a planning condition.
R (Cathie) v Cheshire West and Chester Borough Council [2022] EWHC 2148 (Admin)
Section 31(2A) Senior Courts Act 1981 (highly likely outcome would be the same).
Senior Courts Act 1981, section 31(2A)
Outcomes
Claim failed.
While the council erred in law by not considering whether the discharge of condition 18 prejudiced compliance with condition 14, it was highly likely that the outcome would have been the same even if the error had not occurred. The evidence suggested that step-free access, the core issue, was impossible within the parameters of the original planning permission.